Updated 2026-11-08. Model results with assumed parameters, not measurements. The earlier 2,000-ball run used the flow model's own shot scatter, since shown to be 5-20x too large; those numbers are superseded and shown here as "old".
| Ball | Funnel | Old scatter (superseded) | Calibrated scatter | Calibrated, given launched | Calibrated failure modes (tube and drop, of 2,000) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| POLLEN | Current funnel (53 deg, as built) | 77.8% (75.9-79.5) | 87.8% (86.3-89.2) | 95.3% | tube: fell back out of mouth: 80 drop: bounced out: 4 tube: blocked at mouth rim: 2 tube: stuck inside: 1 |
| POLLEN | Re-aimed 70 deg / mouth +45 mm | 90.9% (89.6-92.1) | 91.8% (90.5-92.9) | 99.6% | tube: fell back out of mouth: 4 drop: bounced out: 3 tube: stuck inside: 1 |
| POLLEN | Re-aimed 70 deg / mouth +55 mm | 90.6% (89.3-91.8) | 91.9% (90.6-93.0) | 99.7% | tube: fell back out of mouth: 4 drop: bounced out: 1 |
| POLLEN | Design of record 65 deg / mouth +55 mm | 91.0% (89.7-92.2)* | 91.0% (89.7-92.2) | 98.8% | drop: bounced out: 21 tube: stuck inside: 1 |
| NECTAR | Current funnel (53 deg, as built) | 0.0% (0.0-0.2) | 0.0% (0.0-0.2) | 0.0% | tube: blocked at mouth rim: 1621 |
| NECTAR | Re-aimed 70 deg / mouth +45 mm | 74.2% (72.2-76.1) | 75.7% (73.8-77.5) | 93.4% | tube: fell back out of mouth: 96 drop: bounced out: 10 tube: stuck inside: 1 |
| NECTAR | Re-aimed 70 deg / mouth +55 mm | 77.5% (75.6-79.3) | 75.2% (73.3-77.0) | 92.8% | tube: fell back out of mouth: 100 drop: bounced out: 16 tube: stuck inside: 1 |
| NECTAR | Design of record 65 deg / mouth +55 mm | 78.9% (77.1-80.6)* | 77.9% (76.0-79.7) | 96.1% | drop: bounced out: 38 tube: fell back out of mouth: 25 |
* The design of record was not in the first study; re-run here with the old (flow-model) scatter on the same chain runs. Bore 95.6 mm (the 103.2 mm sleeve section is below). Intake and feed losses are the same in every row: POLLEN 150 + 7, NECTAR 374 + 5 per 2,000.
| Case | POLLEN | NECTAR |
|---|---|---|
| Azimuth centred on 0 (instead of the flow-model offset) | 91.5% (90.1-92.6) | 77.5% (75.6-79.2) |
| Bore 98 mm | 90.3% (88.9-91.5) | 77.6% (75.7-79.4) |
| Bore 103.2 mm (sleeve section) | 76.3% (74.4-78.2) | 68.7% (66.6-70.7) |
103.2 mm over the whole tube costs about 9 points for NECTAR and 15 for POLLEN (balls bounce out at the drop). The design only has 103.2 mm in the 129 mm vertical sleeve section; that is modelled in the next section and costs about 0.4 points.
| Funnel / ball path | POLLEN | NECTAR | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| per loaded (95% CI) | given launched | per loaded (95% CI) | given launched | |
| Generic study tube (scarf 16 deg), 95.6 mm bore: the earlier 65/55 run | 91.0% (89.7-92.2) | 98.8% | 77.9% (76.0-79.7) | 96.1% |
| Real v6 scarf (A_ 61.6,227.8; B_ 185.9,212.8: 18.1 deg), 95.6 mm bore | 92.0% (90.8-93.2) | 99.9% | 77.0% (75.1-78.8) | 95.0% |
| v6 scarf + the real 103.2 mm sleeve section in the ball path (z 244-373 only) | 92.1% (90.8-93.2) | 99.9% | 76.6% (74.7-78.5) | 94.6% |
| same, tube axis at the CAD x = -7 mm, round funnel | 92.0% (90.8-93.2) | 99.9% | 75.4% (73.5-77.3) | 93.1% |
| same, with the built flats (98 mm wide front) | 92.0% (90.8-93.2) | 99.9% | 75.4% (73.5-77.3) | 93.1% |
| 103.2 mm over the whole path (old worst case, not the design) | 83.2% (81.5-84.8) | 90.3% | 67.2% (65.1-69.2) | 82.9% |
Is any of the ball path 103.2 mm? Yes, but only the sleeve section. The sleeve bore is 103.2 mm and the riser (OD 102.8, ball bore 95.6) only enters its top 19 mm when the tube is up, so the ball travels through an empty 103.2 mm bore from z 244 to z 373 (129 mm, vertical), then steps down to 95.6 mm in the riser, arch and spout. Everywhere else (funnel, bend, riser, arch) the bore is 95.6-96 mm. Modelled as 103.2 mm over that 129 mm only, the cost is about 0.4 points for NECTAR and none for POLLEN; the earlier 9-15 point loss was for 103.2 mm over the whole path, which the design does not have. Not modelled: the 3.8 mm ledge where the ball meets the riser bottom (give it a chamfer).
Flats. The funnel front is trimmed to a flat-sided band 98 mm wide (|x+7| > 49 removed over the 40 mm funnel). In the model no ball ever touches that part of the wall: balls leave the shooter within 17 mm of the tube axis, and even flats only 20 mm wide give identical results. Flats against no flats: no change (POLLEN 92.0% against 92.0%, NECTAR 75.4% against 75.4%, same chain states). The 2 mm axis shift from x = -5 (chain study) to x = -7 (CAD) moved NECTAR down 1.2 points (more fall-backs out of the mouth), within the noise.
| Option | POLLEN | NECTAR | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| picked up | launched | end-to-end FLOWER (95% CI) | vs plan (points) | picked up | launched | end-to-end FLOWER (95% CI) | vs plan (points) | |
| Plan: bar -16, float 60 (grip as assumed) | 92.7% | 92.3% | 90.8% (86.9-94.5) | - | 83.7% | 83.7% | 78.0% (73.2-82.1) | - |
| Plan, roller grip -20% | 89.0% | 88.7% | 88.4% (84.4-92.1) | -2.3 (-5.4..+0.6) | 56.0% | 56.0% | 52.1% (46.4-57.7) | -25.9 (-30.8..-20.6) |
| Plan, roller grip +20% | 95.0% | 94.7% | 94.2% (91.1-96.9) | +3.4 (+0.9..+6.3) | 93.0% | 93.0% | 87.8% (84.4-90.8) | +9.8 (+6.3..+13.7) |
| Spare: bar -20, float 60 | 89.7% | 64.3% | 64.1% (58.3-69.9) | -26.6 (-33.1..-20.7) | 96.7% | 96.7% | 90.8% (88.1-93.2) | +12.7 (+8.8..+17.0) |
| Spare, roller grip -20% | 89.0% | 79.7% | 79.2% (74.4-83.9) | -11.5 (-16.3..-7.2) | 87.0% | 87.0% | 82.7% (78.8-86.3) | +4.6 (+1.2..+8.1) |
| Spare, roller grip +20% | 88.3% | 46.3% | 47.3% (41.6-53.3) | -43.4 (-49.7..-37.4) | 99.3% | 99.3% | 92.8% (90.9-94.2) | +14.7 (+10.5..+19.4) |
Roller grip means the assumed rubber-on-ball friction of the fixed bar (scaled 0.8 or 1.2 on every run). Lost NECTAR are almost all balls pushed ahead of the intake, stuck against the bar and Gecko row: they are lost when the bar grips less than the Gecko (roller friction / Gecko friction below about 1.1). The spare -20 bar helps NECTAR (+12.7) but strands POLLEN at the deck entry (about 1 in 4 enter and jam), so POLLEN falls 27 points. Bench the plan bar -16 first.
| Bar | Scenario | n POLLEN | POLLEN picked up | POLLEN end-to-end | n NECTAR | NECTAR picked up | NECTAR end-to-end |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Plan bar -16 | Single blind pass (the study's default) | 200 | 90.5% (85.6-93.8) | 89.8% (85.3-94.1) | 200 | 82.5% (76.6-87.1) | 78.1% (72.6-83.2) |
| a: robot keeps driving 0.5 s after capture | 200 | 90.5% (85.6-93.8) | 89.8% (85.5-94.3) | 200 | 82.5% (76.6-87.1) | 77.6% (72.1-82.9) | |
| b: ball 0-30 mm from a wall, robot drives into it (60 N push cap) | 200 | 12.0% (8.2-17.2) | 12.8% (8.0-17.8) | 200 | 46.5% (39.7-53.4) | 44.2% (37.3-51.4) | |
| c: ball in a corner (two walls) | 200 | 0.0% (0.0-1.9) | 0.0% (0.0-0.0) | 200 | 13.5% (9.4-18.9) | 0.4% (0.0-1.2) | |
| d: one re-aimed retry after a lost ball | 200 | 99.5% (97.2-99.9) | 99.0% (97.7-99.9) | 200 | 87.0% (81.6-91.0) | 82.0% (77.1-86.3) | |
| Spare bar -20 | Single blind pass (the study's default) | 50 | 86.0% (73.8-93.0) | 62.8% (49.7-76.5) | 100 | 96.0% (90.2-98.4) | 88.8% (84.3-92.4) |
| a: robot keeps driving 0.5 s after capture | 50 | 86.0% (73.8-93.0) | 69.4% (57.3-81.7) | 100 | 96.0% (90.2-98.4) | 89.6% (84.8-93.1) | |
| b: ball 0-30 mm from a wall, robot drives into it (60 N push cap) | 50 | 22.0% (12.8-35.2) | 18.2% (8.3-30.7) | 100 | 36.0% (27.3-45.8) | 31.8% (22.7-40.6) | |
| c: ball in a corner (two walls) | 50 | 0.0% (0.0-7.1) | 0.0% (0.0-0.0) | 100 | 12.0% (7.0-19.8) | 1.8% (0.0-5.5) | |
| d: one re-aimed retry after a lost ball | 50 | 100.0% (92.9-100.0) | 73.6% (61.5-85.5) | 100 | 97.0% (91.5-99.0) | 89.5% (85.0-92.9) | |
| Plan bar -16 | b': same wall, gentle push (20 N cap) | 100 | 76.0% (66.8-83.3) | 75.3% (66.1-82.8) | 100 | 83.0% (74.5-89.1) | 77.5% (70.7-84.0) |
Open floor with one re-aimed retry is the only scenario that clearly beats the blind pass (the retry re-aims x and angle, but the ball and grip are the same, so friction-limited NECTAR losses mostly repeat). Driving on after capture changes nothing. The wall result depends strongly on how hard the robot pushes (a gentle push helps, a hard push crushes the soft ball); the corner is 0% because a corner ball sits outside the 104 mm lane and bar (it needs a different technique). These are untested assumptions; n is 200 per cell for bar -16 (100 NECTAR and 50 POLLEN for the spare).
| Number | POLLEN | NECTAR |
|---|---|---|
| FLOWER, single blind pass (worst case, plan bar) | 92.1% | 76.6% |
| FLOWER, realistic mix, gentle wall push | 88.1% | 76.8% |
| FLOWER, realistic mix, hard wall push | 72.5% | 68.5% |
| HIVE, single blind pass | 58% | 54% |
| HIVE, realistic mix, gentle / hard wall | 55.9% / 45.8% | 54.3% / 48.2% |
HIVE per loaded ball = launched share x HIVE given launched (63.3% POLLEN, 66.5% NECTAR, calibration study). The mix weights are my assumption; there is no match data. The model is not validated against the real robot: goBILDA's stock robot is seen picking up balls in its video, but the notes hold no pickup counts to compare, so the real pickup rate is unknown.
| Ball | Old (flat window, old scatter) | New (3-D CELL, calibrated scatter) | Per loaded ball | Stock 6.0 m/s, no tuning (old / new) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| POLLEN | 12.8% (11.4-14.3) | 63.3% | 58% | 2.1% / 3.9% |
| NECTAR | 9.2% (8.1-10.6) | 66.5% | 54% | 4.0% / 11.5% |
1.5-3.0 m, bearing 0-45 deg, speed tuned per distance and bearing (6.0-9.7 m/s); the stock speed only reaches the CELL at about 0.7-1.7 m. New figures include the corrected 3-D CELL geometry as well as the calibrated scatter.
Source: sim_study/mc2000/RESULTS_calibrated.md, mc_cal.py.